Files
MeanField/experiments/N3_COMPATIBLE_FAMILY_2026-09-19.md

59 lines
3.3 KiB
Markdown
Raw Permalink Normal View History

# Explicit rotating n=3 physical-family control
Branch `research/n3-compatible-family-20260919`; parent `6d423cb`.
This changes experimental physical inputs, not solver equations or production
defaults. It must not be presented as a preconditioner speedup comparison.
The driver normally chooses K for a nonrotating mass-one Lane–Emden star.
The sharp gravitational-energy inequality and the steady virial identity
require, for n=3 and a nonnegative exact-EOS density,
beta = T/|W| <= [1 - (M_LE(K)/M)^(2/3)]/2.
At exactly M=M_LE(K), nonzero rotation is impossible. An independent DOP853
Lane–Emden integration with five tolerance/step/start controls gives the
actual driver's K=0.36393905995216302 a Lane–Emden mass
0.9999999918534539. Thus the numerical K is slightly on the permissible
side, but beta cannot exceed approximately 2.71552e-9. The control-to-control
mass spread is 1.95e-14; this is a numerical sensitivity observation, not a
rigorous interval enclosure. The intended moderate rotation cannot be reached
while retaining that essentially critical mass/K combination.
The optional experiment flag `--n3-K-factor f` multiplies K by a positive
factor, with index required to be exactly three when f differs from one.
The default is one. The analytic seed central density is multiplied by
f^(3/2), keeping its radius equal to the unchanged reference radius. Its
mass becomes approximately f^(3/2), while the target mass remains one.
This is a deliberately off-constraint initial guess, not a density rescaling
during Newton. The public EOS and independent density formulation are unchanged.
The seed's Bernoulli scalar continues to use the target mass; its discrepancy
is part of the initial nonlinear residual and is not hidden by this control.
The bounded first case uses f=.99, J=.035, no central border, the existing
gravity-Schur preconditioner and gravity-curvature trial path, 10 updates,
eta=.03 and absolute nonlinear target 1e-12. The necessary beta bound is then
0.00500000269. This does not guarantee existence, convergence, or identify
a fraction of critical rotation. J already breaks the nonrotating n=3
homology, so this case does not add an extra central-density phase condition.
Before execution, the favorable frozen n=3 field-feedback result motivates
one matched live companion using `stellar-ldu-gravity-schur`. It changes only
the inverse and retains the original ten-update budget, eta=.03, trial path
and physical specifications. The pair is versioned on
`research/n3-live-field-feedback-20260919`; the main convergence report records
the preceding evidence. No success or speedup is assumed from the frozen
eta=.003, J=0, phase-constrained benchmark.
The energy inequality's assumptions are not automatically satisfied by the
discrete independent rho/P(h) fields, approximate gravity, or a central
artificial forcing. This compatibility argument selects a sensible continuum
target; it is not a new density limiter or a substitute for numerical tests.
Primary source: Cheng, Cheng and Lin, equations (1.14)–(1.15) and Theorem 3.1,
[Expanding solutions near unstable Lane–Emden stars](https://arxiv.org/html/2305.10218#S3.SS1).
The displayed beta bound is our consequence of their inequality and
2T+W+3 integral(P)=0. Their G=1 convention matches this diagnostic.
Independent integration evidence is retained in
`../../diagnostics/n3_mass_compatibility_2026-09-19/`.